You have to hit "Quote" on every post you want to quote and then "Post Reply" at the very top. Then your multiple quotes get inserted in your reply.
Press the Quote button on each post you want to quote, you will see in the top left of the page the red Post Reply button, this will have the number of posts you are quoting in brackets, press Post Reply and it will put all the quoted posts in the quick reply box at the bottom
You can type your message at the bottom or reply to each one, your message should start for each quote after the [ QUOTE ] tag, Press reply and your post is done.
Thanks John
Pete
Ian M
commented