Scale Model Shop

Collapse

Which was really better, The Mosquito or the Me 410?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • selrach
    • Apr 2009
    • 180

    #1

    Which was really better, The Mosquito or the Me 410?

    Due to it's legendary service, it would seem the Dehavilland Mossie hands down was the best. Recently I looked into the performance details of both planes and the was 410B had powerful engines and comparable speed. Both aircraft are similar in shape with protruding engines set close to the fuselage for better maneuverability. The Mossie, constructed of wood as it was, made it more stealthy. The Brit also had better, more compact radar. Was this then the major advantage? Or was it how the planes were used? If the RAF and Germans had swapped planes, would the RAF still dominate just because they used their resources more cleverly?
  • boatman
    SMF Supporters
    • Nov 2018
    • 14447
    • christopher
    • NORFOLK UK

    #2
    HI Selrach well I never heard of a ME 410 could you put up A PIC OF ONE please
    chris SORRY GUYS DINT NOTICE THE DATE OF THIS THREAD

    Comment

    • topgazza
      SMF Supporters
      • Jan 2020
      • 640

      #3
      Do you mean the 110 ?

      Comment

      • BattleshipBob
        SMF Supporters
        • Apr 2018
        • 6785
        • Bob
        • Cardiff

        #4
        The 410 was the replacement for the 110

        Comment

        • boatman
          SMF Supporters
          • Nov 2018
          • 14447
          • christopher
          • NORFOLK UK

          #5
          Originally posted by topgazza
          Do you mean the 110 ?
          HI Gary sorry to mislead you but I don't think we will find out as that post was 3 yrs ago
          chris

          Comment

          • boatman
            SMF Supporters
            • Nov 2018
            • 14447
            • christopher
            • NORFOLK UK

            #6
            Originally posted by Bobthestug
            The 410 was the replacement for the 110
            HI Bob m8 thanks for comin to the recuse an could you put up a pic of the ME 410 ? CHRIS

            Comment

            • topgazza
              SMF Supporters
              • Jan 2020
              • 640

              #7
              I think this could start a new trend. Answering posts that ended years ago :tears-of-joy::tears-of-joy:

              Comment

              • topgazza
                SMF Supporters
                • Jan 2020
                • 640

                #8
                It looks like the Blenheim

                Comment

                • boatman
                  SMF Supporters
                  • Nov 2018
                  • 14447
                  • christopher
                  • NORFOLK UK

                  #9
                  Originally posted by topgazza
                  I think this could start a new trend. Answering posts that ended years ago :tears-of-joy::tears-of-joy:
                  Well Gary at least its something new :smiling: :smiling: :smiling:
                  chris

                  Comment

                  • boatman
                    SMF Supporters
                    • Nov 2018
                    • 14447
                    • christopher
                    • NORFOLK UK

                    #10
                    Originally posted by topgazza
                    Thanks Gary but I think it looks YUK compared to the mossie
                    chris

                    Comment

                    • topgazza
                      SMF Supporters
                      • Jan 2020
                      • 640

                      #11
                      I agree. Its a bit of a copy with the cockpit so forward. Copying the Blenheim or the Beaufighter.

                      But regarding answering old posts as a new thing. We could always answer the thread before that one in the new thread. Just like

                      Comment

                      • Tim Marlow
                        SMF Supporters
                        • Apr 2018
                        • 18882
                        • Tim
                        • Somerset UK

                        #12
                        The 410 was Messerschmidt making the best of the total failure that was the 210......which was supposed to replace the 110.....

                        Comment

                        • topgazza
                          SMF Supporters
                          • Jan 2020
                          • 640

                          #13
                          So they didn't always get the engineering right

                          Comment

                          • AlanG
                            • Dec 2008
                            • 6296

                            #14
                            Some of the Germans late war aircraft were fantastic designs. Such as the Fw190 D9/11/13 and the Me262. If they had been introduced earlier (when they were actually developed) instead of the bureaucracy limited introduction timescale, then the air war could have been seriously damaged and delayed.

                            The Me410 was a decent design and as was mentioned above, was introduced as a replacement for the Me210 (which had a stability design fault). The rearward facing guns was a bit of a gimmick and added a lot of weight to the structure. If these had been removed then the Me410 performance figures would have looked a lot better. It was also a very good heavy attack fighter against bombers. But when the superior allied air supremacy came to it's domination, they were shot down in droves (bit like the Me110 G2 and Fw190 A8/R2 or R8).

                            All in all the mossie was a better aircraft resource wise and could carry a far better bomb load and external stores load.

                            Comment

                            • Guest

                              #15
                              Originally posted by Tim Marlow
                              The 410 was Messerschmidt making the best of the total failure that was the 210......
                              Total failure in the Luftwaffe, anyway. The Hungarians apparently liked them much better than the Germans did, so that makes me wonder what they did that the Germans didn’t. Could be a case similar to the F4U Corsair, which the Americans considered too dangerous to operate off aircraft carriers while the British happily (? ) did just that.

                              Since nobody posted a picture of an Me 410 for boatman, here’s one:

                              [ATTACH]372968[/ATTACH] (via Rod’s Warbirds)

                              And in case you’re wondering how it differs from an Me 210:

                              [ATTACH]372969[/ATTACH] (Wikipedia)

                              Originally posted by topgazza
                              I think this could start a new trend. Answering posts that ended years ago :tears-of-joy::tears-of-joy:
                              The name for this phenomenon is “thread necromancy”.

                              Comment

                              Working...