Scale Model Shop

Collapse

Not a Moment to Lose… Battle of the Bulge, Ardennes, December 1944

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • TIM FORSTER
    • Apr 2018
    • 283
    • TIM
    • LONDON, UK

    #136
    Telling the story, potential figures… and how to add a feeling of jeopardy

    Click image for larger version

Name:	PXL_20240721_121145597.jpg
Views:	98
Size:	5.4 KB
ID:	1230354

    Here is the backstory as it now stands:

    The early stages of the advance of the Kampfgruppe brings an SS recce unit into a Belgian farmyard (recently abandoned by the occupants who, for the last few weeks at least, had been living with the relief of Allied liberation). The Germans are confident - so far they have made rapid progress against little or no opposition - but the experienced panzer grenadiers are understandably wary.

    Unknown to these (re)invaders, the farm is now occupied by some American GIs. Their recent experience is told by the broken-down jeep (perhaps shot up during a rapid retreat). They have taken refuge in the farmyard, but as they try to fix their vehicle, they hear the sound of approaching engines and tracks. Friend or foe? Looking out of an upstairs window, to their horror they realise that they are in a very dangerous position…

    When I started this build I thought that I had a pretty clear idea of what tale I was trying to tell. I always conceived this diorama as an ‘encounter scenario’… hence the title. Yet I cannot claim that I had everything planned from the start. I have nothing but admiration for those modellers who can settle on everything at the outset of a project, but I suspect that for most of us ideas just evolve. How dramatic should it be? How many figures would I need? What exactly would they be doing?

    The position of the building was always intended to create a natural division between the left / lower part of the scene and the right / higher area. But it was also designed to break the line of sight - that way the idea that both sides might find themselves surprised by the other made more sense.

    Click image for larger version

Name:	PXL_20240303_150028456.jpg
Views:	97
Size:	4.7 KB
ID:	1230355

    In the early shot above I had started to work out the relative position of the vehicles and figures.

    Click image for larger version

Name:	PXL_20240721_121327074.jpg
Views:	98
Size:	5.6 KB
ID:	1230356

    A pivotal figure in the composition is this SS panzer grenadier from Alpine.
    Click image for larger version

Name:	12 SS HJ Grenadier Set AL35060.jpg
Views:	96
Size:	2.8 KB
ID:	1230357
    Not only a magnificent piece of sculpting and resin casting, but also a very great pose. Although I have seen this figure used in Normandy scenarios, he might just as easily fit into the Ardennes (I may add some gloves!)

    He is also a useful focal point: his forward stoop and out-stretched left arm help to take the viewer’s attention around the corner where his looking, but also back to the vehicles and other troops who are dismounting and coming up behind him.

    Because they have yet to find out what is lurking around the corner, I can probably go for some more relaxed poses for the rest. Obviously I still have much work to do here, because I’m working on the basis of two men in or around the Schwimmwagen (the photos from Kaiserbaracke Crossroads clearly show that each had a two-man crew) and another six from the 250 halftrack. So that’s a mere eight figures, almost all dressed in SS camo smocks… oh dear!

    But what of the Americans? Well, at least here I am limited by the carrying capacity of the Jeep (four at the most). Looking around for potential figures, I couldn’t find many resin options in suitable action poses. In fact, in the world of Alpine, etc most GIs seem to spend all their time just lounging around!

    Luckily there are plenty of other options out there, especially from Master Box and Mini Art:

    Click image for larger version

Name:	MAS35130.jpg
Views:	98
Size:	7.2 KB
ID:	1230359

    Click image for larger version

Name:	PXL_20240721_220650457.jpg
Views:	98
Size:	7.6 KB
ID:	1230358

    From the Master Box Move! Move! Move! set I have already started to cobble together a figure of a GI running away from the rapidly evolving situation. This is early days: he’s just white-tacked together with a Hornet head, but the pose is energetic and he looks like he’s running for his life… Those gaiters will probably have to go.

    Click image for larger version

Name:	PXL_20240304_190132129.jpg
Views:	98
Size:	4.5 KB
ID:	1230363

    From the Miniart Close Combat US Tank Crew set there’s a great figure looking around a corner with his grease gun. By swapping the legs and adding an Alpine head I think I have found the guy who is about to face-off with the SS grenadier…

    Click image for larger version

Name:	PXL_20240721_121133392.jpg
Views:	95
Size:	6.6 KB
ID:	1230360

    So why a tanker and a GI? Well I’m going to use the excuse that this is a mixed bag of soldiers who were driving somewhere when they ran into the German advance. Maybe the tank crewman (who is probably going to be an officer) was hitching a ride with some infantry.

    Anyway, the takeaway from all of this is that sometimes you need to create the landscape before you can really begin to populate it. At least, that’s my excuse and I’m sticking to it!

    Click image for larger version

Name:	PXL_20240721_121039416.jpg
Views:	96
Size:	5.4 KB
ID:	1230361

    Hopefully, there’s quite a bit of other progress that you can see here: the Jeep, the tree, etc. I will be covering these in more detail very soon…

    Comment

    • Neil Merryweather
      SMF Supporters
      • Dec 2018
      • 5177
      • London

      #137
      I'm loving your thinking Tim, and I love the logic for the tanker; anyway it's your model so why not?
      And what a fantastic piece of diorama building already!

      Comment

      • Steve Ski
        • Jul 2024
        • 222

        #138
        The scenario looks like it's working, Tim. Mixed units were all over, so that's not a stretch at all. This has come a long way and it's starting to mesh well.

        Ruck On, and thanks for the warm welcome, Brother!

        P.S. A little ad-lib never hurt nobody

        Comment

        • rtfoe
          SMF Supporters
          • Apr 2018
          • 9065

          #139
          Originally posted by TIM FORSTER
          Thanks Richard. I'm almost afraid to ask about the monkeys... Did you try to make some?!
          Yes I did Tim, 16 of them. You see them being made scrolling midway through my blog Malayan Emergency Dio.
          They're ugly as hell.

          Cheers,
          Wabble

          Comment

          • rtfoe
            SMF Supporters
            • Apr 2018
            • 9065

            #140
            Hi Tim, more precise page Malayan Emergency Monkeys showing the painted troop doing the macarena.

            Your Dio is evolving as it goes as it's good you have found the right figures. Tweaking the plan and composition as little as possible is the norm in Dio making. Just like you I'm also in awe with those who have the picture and composition fixed from the very beginning.

            Cheers,
            Wabble

            Comment

            • TIM FORSTER
              • Apr 2018
              • 283
              • TIM
              • LONDON, UK

              #141
              Originally posted by rtfoe
              Yes I did Tim, 16 of them. You see them being made scrolling midway through my blog Malayan Emergency Dio.
              They're ugly as hell.

              Cheers,
              Wabble
              Richard I have already made amends and left comments on your amazing zoological adventures...

              I will be having at least one animal in my diorama - but will leave it for you to guess until it appears. Clue: it will tie in with the fleeing GI and the tree...

              Comment

              • rtfoe
                SMF Supporters
                • Apr 2018
                • 9065

                #142
                I've seen the lovely comments, Tim, thanks.
                I don't think it will be chickens or ducks but I'm guessing it may be a fleeing squirrel since there is a connection to a tree but who knows...surprise me. :smiling2:

                Cheers,
                Wabble

                Comment

                • Jukebox64
                  SMF Supporters
                  • Aug 2024
                  • 161

                  #143
                  Originally posted by TIM FORSTER
                  [ATTACH=CONFIG]n1206552[/ATTACH]

                  Well, I’m back! Rumours of my demise have been greatly exaggerated, etc…

                  Looking back I can see that it was November 21 that I finished my last project:



                  Coming before that one was this:



                  Sorry it has been so long. It’s all the usual excuses: work, family, life, etc. I haven’t even been much of a lurker…

                  But I have not been entirely idle!

                  When I was in my first modelling phase as a teenager back in the early 80s I had always wanted to build a Battle of the Bulge diorama. I can still recall the rush of excitement when I finally bought this book (published in 1984):

                  [ATTACH=CONFIG]n1206553[/ATTACH]

                  It was a HUGE inspiration. It also wasn’t cheap! As a comprehensive work of scholarship accompanied by all those maps and photos (many in the classic Then and Now format) I still don’t think it has really been surpassed, although there have been many excellent works published since.

                  Of course, there has been a lot more written about the history of this particular conflict since then, with the ‘Duel in the Mist’ series of books being a particular highlight.

                  We are all familiar with many of the images of the Ardennes offensive, such as a King Tiger crowded with Fallschirmjäger, or heavily armed Panzer Grenadiers posing in front of knocked out American vehicles at Poteau. Then there are the cine films showing the advance of Kampfgruppe Peiper into Stavelot.

                  It is worth noting that most of these come from the German side, taken during the early phase of the campaign. Ironically, many of these images survive today because they were captured by the Americans quite early on during the battle and then used in newsreels.

                  Then there are many more photographs taken later in the battle, mostly from the Allied perspective, usually showing destroyed German equipment and shattered buildings - often covered in snow (we will come back to that in due course).

                  Of course, there have also been a lot of dioramas inspired by these events - so many, in fact, that it might be said that the whole idea of depicting a scene from the Battle of the Bulge (a title that itself now seems somewhat dated) in model form has become something of a cliché.

                  So what to do? Well I am not going to lay claim to trying anything totally new here - but I am going to try and give it a slightly fresh spin. I am also going to avoid tanks, although, as you will already have spotted from the first picture, there is going to be an Sdkfz 250 Neu halftrack and a Schwimmwagen - plus a Jeep.

                  [ATTACH=CONFIG]n1206554[/ATTACH]

                  Above: SS-Oberscharführer and SS-Unterscharführer of 1. SS-Panzer-Division 'LSSAH', SS-Panzer-Aufklärungs-Abteilung 1 at the Kaiserbaracke crossroads on the road between Saint-Vith and Malmedy, probably 17th/18th December 1944

                  So the setting here is a moment during the first days of the German offensive - most likely the 17th or 18th December. Unlike my last diorama, this one is not based on any particular event, but a possible scenario. Elements of a German Reconnaissance Unit from 1st SS Panzer Division Leibstandarte SS Adolf Hitler have pulled up in front of a farmhouse during the advance through American lines. Despite the breakthrough and the initial euphoria that many of the soldiers may have felt, the commanders already knew that things were not going to plan and progress has been too slow.

                  The Recce group have arrived in a Schwimmwagen and 250 halftrack and troops dismount. An officer studies his map and checks his watch. Meanwhile, out of sight behind the building, an escaping Jeep has broken down. Realising that the enemy has just arrived, the GIs abandon their vehicle and beat a hasty retreat away from the farm and up the hill. Hearing the noise, some of the German troops move to investigate.

                  So the title is supposed to reflect the predicament of both sides at a brief moment in time when the Germans seemed to have the advantage and the Allies appeared to be losing - and yet we all know how things were to turn out!

                  Here are few shots showing my early attempts to work out the composition.

                  [ATTACH=CONFIG]n1206555[/ATTACH]

                  [ATTACH=CONFIG]n1206556[/ATTACH]

                  Part of the challenge I have faced has been to position the farmhouse so that it screens the abandoned Jeep from the advancing Germans without cutting the whole diorama in half…

                  Once I had the general idea I laid out the vehicles (or at least their shells) and decided what size and shape the base should be. All my previous dioramas have been rectangular, but I felt it was time to try something a little more daring - so I drew a shape that had curved ends but a straight middle section (a rhomboid rectangle?)

                  [ATTACH=CONFIG]n1206557[/ATTACH]
                  [ATTACH=CONFIG]n1206558[/ATTACH]
                  [ATTACH=CONFIG]n1206559[/ATTACH]

                  Ignore the stray British infantryman - he's just there for a bit of scale.

                  On the plus side the choice of shape means that I will have less corners to fill. On the downside, making the edging is going to be a nightmare!

                  I also started to construct a mock-up of the building. As you can see, this is just a rough cut from cardboard off-cuts held together with masking tape - but this was enough to convince me that the shape and dimensions of the base were more or less correct.

                  Having worked out the dimensions of the base I then cut out two pieces of card and used double-sided tape to attach these to both sides of a piece of low-density foam (the sort used for ceiling insulation which can be picked up for free from most building sites).

                  I have used this foam for both my previous projects because it is a) very cheap (i.e. free) and b) very easy to carve. However, it is also very messy. First I used a saw to carve the block into the approximate shape and then sanding blocks to refine it.

                  [ATTACH=CONFIG]n1206560[/ATTACH]
                  [ATTACH=CONFIG]n1206561[/ATTACH]

                  It is at this point that I find myself getting excited - and nervous. Basically, you have everything you need in front of you, but you also have to get rid of what you don’t!

                  After an hour or so of sawing, sanding, chiseling (and goodness knows what else) I ended up with this:

                  [ATTACH=CONFIG]n1206562[/ATTACH]
                  [ATTACH=CONFIG]n1206563[/ATTACH]
                  [ATTACH=CONFIG]n1206564[/ATTACH]

                  There is still a long way to go, but at this point I could see the whole thing beginning to look something like what I had in my mind's eye. You will also notice that the 250, Schwim and Jeep are also starting to take shape.

                  More to come…
                  In 2016 my wife and I took a band of brothers tour across Europe. We started out in Normandy and went to all of the beaches and eventually worked our way across Germany. The way easy company did and ended up at Hitler’s tea room, the Eagles nest in Berches Garden. My wife and I stood right outside of this church that you’re doing the diorama of they even still have a parachute and a dummy hanging up there as a memorial to that soldier they got stuck and shot while he was on the roof, jumping in from the plane. we also went into the Arden Forest and I got to set and a fighting hole. That was Doug by US serviceman during the battle of the bulge. It was one of the best moments of my entire life.

                  Comment

                  • tr1ckey66
                    SMF Supporters
                    • Mar 2009
                    • 3592

                    #144
                    Hi Tim
                    Just catching up with the updates on this fabulous diorama. It’s looking awesome. The composition of the diorama is just spot on with events leading the viewer around the scene. And the sheer modelling skill and attention to detail is an inspiration.

                    Brilliant stuff
                    Cheers
                    Paul

                    Comment

                    • TIM FORSTER
                      • Apr 2018
                      • 283
                      • TIM
                      • LONDON, UK

                      #145
                      Dear all,

                      I have held off asking about this because I have read other posts and I understand that there is a time lag in the old forum pics being re-uploaded to the site. And I get that.

                      I have also held off posting on my own blog because I have been awaiting for the 'magic' to happen. It's obviously more than a bit dispiriting to have spent over a year posting on one topic only to see all my carefully edited and curated images shrivel to the size and quality of a fuzzy postage stamp!

                      But having looked on the site today I have come across at least one blog in the Diorama category where the pictures are all present and correct in their original size and definition.

                      I am hoping that this is a good news, but I would welcome reassurance, having been a member of this site for many years (and a paying supporter). Is there some sort of 'last posted first restored' policy (which makes sense if they are working backwards). Should I remain optimistic? Can anyone reasssure me?

                      Thanks, Tim

                      Comment

                      • Mini Me
                        SMF Supporters
                        • Jun 2018
                        • 10711

                        #146
                        Good luck Tim....I don't think anyone is holding their breath on this one.?

                        Comment

                        • Steven000
                          SMF Supporters
                          • Aug 2018
                          • 2820
                          • Steven
                          • Belgium

                          #147
                          Hi Tim, the pictures posted 'after' the changeover are all normal, but all the images before that are still thumbnails.

                          They would be working on a script to automise and restore the old pictures, but I guess it has been given a low priority or it's just too hard to make it work...

                          Hope you'll resume posting updates though.
                          Cheers

                          Comment

                          • Ian M
                            Administrator
                            • Dec 2008
                            • 18259
                            • Ian
                            • Falster, Denmark

                            #148
                            Originally posted by TIM FORSTER
                            But having looked on the site today I have come across at least one blog in the Diorama category where the pictures are all present and correct in their original size and definition.
                            Could you provide a link to that please?
                            Without seeing the offending thread, I can only guess that the poster has used pictures "off site" on an image server so they are unaffected by the technical issue of converting 40GB of image data and matching them to the correct text entries.
                            Group builds

                            Bismarck

                            Comment

                            • TIM FORSTER
                              • Apr 2018
                              • 283
                              • TIM
                              • LONDON, UK

                              #149
                              Originally posted by Ian M
                              Could you provide a link to that please?
                              Without seeing the offending thread, I can only guess that the poster has used pictures "off site" on an image server so they are unaffected by the technical issue of converting 40GB of image data and matching them to the correct text entries.
                              Hi Ian,

                              Thanks for yoir interest and I want to stress that I am not a moaner and appreciate what you guys are all doing!

                              The thread I have found where all the earlier pics look in good shape is this one:

                              This idea, and following concept, was started over 11 years ago and has been worked at various times until reaching a stopping point. To get everyone up to speed and carry on to completion I am posting the thread starting at its current stage restarted back in January. All comments are welcome, of course ;) Restart “Easy


                              I have already asked Ski privately how he did it and I'm waiting for a reply...

                              Regards, Tim

                              Comment

                              • Ian M
                                Administrator
                                • Dec 2008
                                • 18259
                                • Ian
                                • Falster, Denmark

                                #150
                                They are, as I suspected, on an image server so the images are not actually on this forum, thus they all appear as normal.
                                Group builds

                                Bismarck

                                Comment

                                Working...