Scale Model Shop

Collapse

When did Tamiya get good?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Mrchickenstrips
    • Jul 2022
    • 32

    #1

    When did Tamiya get good?

    We all know Tamiya is excellent when it comes to fit and engineering, but when did this trend start? Some of their older kits are real doozies i.e. 1/48 Sea Harrier. Withen the last 5 or so years, we've been given some lovely aircraft models (Bf-109G, Spitfire Mk.1, Phantom, Tomcat, P-38, F-35) So when did this start? Is there a certain kit that could be considered the beginning of good Tamiya?
  • BarryW
    SMF Supporters
    • Jul 2011
    • 6010

    #2
    I remember a Tamiya kits were excellent, much better than Airfix or Revell back in the early ‘70’s. That’s not to say that every single kit was up to standard and you are correct about that Harrier. But remember, what was good in the 70’s would be regarded as poor now, so it’s all relative.

    Comment

    • langy71
      SMF Supporters
      • Apr 2018
      • 1948
      • Chris
      • Nottingham

      #3
      Originally posted by BarryW
      I remember a Tamiya kits were excellent, much better than Airfix or Revell back in the early ‘70’s. That’s not to say that every single kit was up to standard and you are correct about that Harrier. But remember, what was good in the 70’s would be regarded as poor now, so it’s all relative.
      The best thing about the Tamiya Sea Harrier was the pilot..

      Comment

      • Mrchickenstrips
        • Jul 2022
        • 32

        #4
        Do you guys think they should market their old kits into a 'classics' range similar to Airfix?

        Comment

        • Dave Ward
          SMF Supporters
          • Apr 2018
          • 10549

          #5
          Judging by the number of Tammy 1/48 Sea Harriers for sale on ebay - a lot of people bought it, looked in the box & immediately decided to sell it! To be fair it's the only Tamiya kit that I would describe as bad. Quite a few mediocre ones, but their overall makeability puts Tamiya above other makers..........
          Dave

          Comment

          • langy71
            SMF Supporters
            • Apr 2018
            • 1948
            • Chris
            • Nottingham

            #6
            Originally posted by Dave Ward
            Judging by the number of Tammy 1/48 Sea Harriers for sale on ebay - a lot of people bought it, looked in the box & immediately decided to sell it! To be fair it's the only Tamiya kit that I would describe as bad. Quite a few mediocre ones, but their overall makeability puts Tamiya above other makers..........
            Dave
            Wasn't the engine 'despite being a full one' pretty poor ? I suppose it would have been a good base for some scratchery

            Comment

            • Guest

              #7
              Originally posted by Mrchickenstrips
              We all know Tamiya is excellent when it comes to fit and engineering, but when did this trend start?
              The 1960s? I don’t think there has ever been a Tamiya kit with poorly fitting parts. Sure, the odd couple of parts may not fit that great on the odd kit, but in general, any Tamiya kit you care to buy, whether it’s the latest or one that was released 50 years ago, will fit better than those of many other manufacturers.

              Comment

              • KarlW
                • Jul 2020
                • 1522

                #8
                I binned my Tamiya Shar, then bought a Kinetic one.
                One of Tamiyas dogs.
                But yes they've always had a good reputation, a better question would be when did everyone else up their game?

                Comment

                • Mrchickenstrips
                  • Jul 2022
                  • 32

                  #9
                  Originally posted by KarlW
                  I binned my Tamiya Shar, then bought a Kinetic one.
                  One of Tamiyas dogs.
                  But yes they've always had a good reputation, a better question would be when did everyone else up their game?
                  That's a good question, when did we start to see better kits out of other manufacturers. Eastern Europe has a lit of good manufacturers these days.

                  Comment

                  • The Smythe Meister
                    • Jan 2019
                    • 6248

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Mrchickenstrips
                    We all know Tamiya is excellent when it comes to fit and engineering, but when did this trend start? Some of their older kits are real doozies i.e. 1/48 Sea Harrier. Withen the last 5 or so years, we've been given some lovely aircraft models (Bf-109G, Spitfire Mk.1, Phantom, Tomcat, P-38, F-35) So when did this start? Is there a certain kit that could be considered the beginning of good Tamiya?
                    To my mind you should be asking ," When did Tamiya get BAD?!! ...
                    Not sure when you started to model properly, but I remember as a kid,back in the mid '70s,they were the kits you aspired to actually being able to buy , :smiling3:
                    ... that's obviously a long time ago, but I must admit,I kinda remember those wishful days fondly ....
                    ..... and of course ,we can now see they're still cracking builds... even ones that are still '70s ,(or even older),molds

                    Comment

                    • Dave Ward
                      SMF Supporters
                      • Apr 2018
                      • 10549

                      #11
                      I don't think that Tamiya has become bad, I think that they haven't advanced as much as some of the newer manufacturers, maybe a case of resting on their laurels. Tamiya also have a big market for their r/c models, so maybe the emphasis on standard kits has a lower priority?
                      Dave

                      Comment

                      • BarryW
                        SMF Supporters
                        • Jul 2011
                        • 6010

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Dave Ward
                        I don't think that Tamiya has become bad, I think that they haven't advanced as much as some of the newer manufacturers, maybe a case of resting on their laurels. Tamiya also have a big market for their r/c models, so maybe the emphasis on standard kits has a lower priority?
                        Dave
                        I really don’t think you can say that at all Dave.

                        OK, they have not issued a new 1/32 WW2 warbird for a few years but their last couple, the Corsair and Mossie are right up there at the top of the pile and still way ahead competitors. Indeed all the 32 scale warbirds are right at the top. Then there are their more recent 1/48 releases, the F4B and F14 that I have in the stash, likewise, simply among the very best that you can get.

                        So no Dave, they are right up there at the top and the only company that comes close to them in quality and innovation is Zoukei Mura.

                        Comment

                        • JR
                          • May 2015
                          • 18273

                          #13
                          I've only built a couple of armour kits , probably made in the late 90s and they have been a dream, clean of flash and well detailed . The figures have not be bad either .

                          Comment

                          • Jon Heptonstall
                            SMF Supporters
                            • Apr 2018
                            • 1704

                            #14
                            I remember getting my first Tamiya for Christmas in 1976ish-the Sd.Kfz 222 and thinking it was great.The only option otherwise was Airfix and a few Matchbox kits and the difference was massive.These old kits are still around but have been well overtaken by other manufacturers so I'd agree with Dave in saying they have always been good but such a lot of others are now better.Tamiya can still produce excellent models but not often.Mind you,some of their recent figures are very,very good.I'm only talking about their 1/35 stuff here.
                            Jon.

                            Comment

                            • BarryW
                              SMF Supporters
                              • Jul 2011
                              • 6010

                              #15
                              Originally posted by Jon Heptonstall
                              I remember getting my first Tamiya for Christmas in 1976ish-the Sd.Kfz 222 and thinking it was great.The only option otherwise was Airfix and a few Matchbox kits and the difference was massive.These old kits are still around but have been well overtaken by other manufacturers so I'd agree with Dave in saying they have always been good but such a lot of others are now better.Tamiya can still produce excellent models but not often.Mind you,some of their recent figures are very,very good.I'm only talking about their 1/35 stuff here.
                              Jon.
                              But all companies reissue old kits. You can only compare with the new tools. While Tamiya are not prolific in their new launches there is still a steady flow. I am not an armour modeller and have not built one for many years so I can only speak for their aircraft and Tammy are top of the game.

                              Comment

                              Working...