Scale Model Shop

Collapse

12th Hitlerjugend SS Panzer Division in Normandy - Tim Saunders & Richard Hone (book review)

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • AlanG
    • Dec 2008
    • 6296

    #1

    12th Hitlerjugend SS Panzer Division in Normandy - Tim Saunders & Richard Hone (book review)

    Title: 12th Hitlerjugend SS Panzer Division in Normandy
    Authors: Tim Saunders & Richard Hone
    Publisher: Pen & Sword Military
    ISBN:978-1-52675-736-4
    Pages: 315

    Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_2511.JPG
Views:	2
Size:	2.7 KB
ID:	1169826Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_2512.JPG
Views:	2
Size:	2.5 KB
ID:	1169827

    This is a comprehensive record of the actions undertaken by 12.SS.Pz.Div in Normandy from just before Operation Overlord through to the closure of the Falaise Gap.

    It starts off with a brief chapter on how the 12th SS Panzer Division came into being and a little about the training they received. It's a good insight into the reasoning behind the setting up of the division of 17 year old 'kids' and how they received help from other SS divisions to give them valuable insight and experience of what real war was actually about, and not what they had seen in the propaganda films of the day. Giving accounts of the divisions deployment to France and the Normandy area, it pulls no punches with the war crimes committed on the way to Normandy either.

    The majority of the book is then written from D-Day (6th June) onwards. Giving excellent accounts of the battles from both the German and Allied sides. The constant hardships that they faced in finding food, lack of sleep, lack of ammunition and terrible orders from those back in Berlin. Losing key personnel along the way and how they overcame these problems. Like in any war, people will always step up to the mantle and make a difference.
    The accounts of fighting against the British, Canadian and Polish troops with their air superiority, artillery support (Army & Navy) is truly mind-blowing. Factual numbers of personnel and tanks lost on both sides is staggering. The 12th SS Panzer Division alone lost about 8000 personnel in the 10 weeks of fighting.

    Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_2513.JPG
Views:	2
Size:	2.5 KB
ID:	1169828Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_2514.JPG
Views:	2
Size:	2.6 KB
ID:	1169830

    Something which did surprise me was the documentation giving examples of war crimes committed by Allied soldiers. Whilst I knew it was a possibility, it is something you very rarely read about. But it goes into quite good detail behind them and also the reason why they took place (and subsequently stopped for a while).

    Whilst there are quite a few pictures in it that I have seen over the years on the internet, the book has still provided a few more that I have not seen. It also gives very short explanations about certain ones in the book such as the very famous one of Sturmmann Otto Funk. He has that 1000 yard stare that you have heard about and seen with long time combat veterans. Well in the picture it explains why he has that stare.

    Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_2515.JPG
Views:	2
Size:	3.1 KB
ID:	1169831

    All in all this is a fantastic book for anyone wanting to know more about the conflict with the British, Canadian and Polish armies in Normandy. I have no problem in recommending this book.
  • Dave Ward
    SMF Supporters
    • Apr 2018
    • 10549

    #2
    Alan,
    interesting, about war crimes committed by Allied soldiers - my late father, Captain in the Black Watch, said that German snipers were regularly shot out of hand, and sometimes prisoners never made it to the rear holding areas. He also told me that during any assault he was careful to keep somewhat behind the front runners, as he said that some of them lost all sense of discrimination between friend & foe. All of this was never reported, or referred to. These conversations usually took place after a fair amount of alcohol had been consumed, normally he never talked about the subject.
    Dave

    Comment

    • JR
      • May 2015
      • 18273

      #3
      The side of war that no one likes to admit too .

      Comment

      • Airborne01
        • Mar 2021
        • 3954
        • Steve
        • Essex

        #4
        An excellent book Alan; it's a definite truism that the victors re-write history!
        Steve

        Comment

        • adt70hk
          SMF Supporters
          • Sep 2019
          • 10400

          #5
          Thanks Alan. Interesting overview. :thumb2: :thumb2:

          Might have to add it to my list of potential books.....

          Comment

          • AlanG
            • Dec 2008
            • 6296

            #6
            Cheers guys. I really did like reading this book. Gave me knowledge of something that we rarely hear about. The enemies side of things. Also highlighted in great detail the total waste of life in the conflict (and war in general). Another little side note was the amount of friendly fire that happened on the allied side. Quite shocking really.

            Since reading it i've become a little obsessed with the Panzer IV. Thanks to Scalemates, i now have a load of them in my 'wish list' lol

            Comment

            • adt70hk
              SMF Supporters
              • Sep 2019
              • 10400

              #7
              Originally posted by AlanG
              Cheers guys. I really did like reading this book. Gave me knowledge of something that we rarely hear about. The enemies side of things. Also highlighted in great detail the total waste of life in the conflict (and war in general). Another little side note was the amount of friendly fire that happened. Quite shocking really.

              Since reading it i've become a little obsessed with the Panzer IV. Thanks to Scalemates, i now have a load of them in my 'wish list' lol
              Thanks Alan.......will definitely consider it for the future!! :thumb2::thumb2:

              Although given that I acquired two JG300 109 G-6s shortly after reading 'Defending the Reich' that you recommended about its sister units JG301 and 302, it might not be such a good idea!:smiling5:

              In all seriousness though thanks again fort the review!!

              ATB

              Andrew

              Comment

              Working...