Scale Model Shop

Collapse

Harder & Steinbeck Colani Airbrush review.

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • BarryW
    SMF Supporters
    • Jul 2011
    • 6010

    #1

    Harder & Steinbeck Colani Airbrush review.

    First a bit of background.

    I have used several brands of airbrush over the years, a cheap Chinese knock-off, Harder & Steinbeck Evolution and Infinity, GSI Creos PS275, Topnotch and Iwata. Of all of them, I like the H&S brushes most due to their very easy breakdown and easy clean up. They are also precision instruments, but the same can be said for the Iwata, Creos and Topnotch brushes too.

    I only moved away (partially, I still have an Infinity in use) from H&S because I found my finger cramping during long sessions and on discovering the Topnotch with a trigger control, I have only bought trigger/pistol grip airbrushes since.

    I was aware of the H&S Colani, with its trigger/pistol grip, but always thought it more a spray gun than a precision airbrush, which is exactly what it looks like, and ignored it.

    After I over-tightened the nozzle on my trusty PS275 sheering it off, I decided on a new airbrush. I originally thought to get another PS275 but had a look around at what else is available. Consequently I had a look at what H&S had and still their only trigger/pistol grip brush is the Colani and so I decided to take another look.

    Immediately I discovered that it comes with a .4 needle, not just the larger .8 plus needles, with the ability to add a .2 needle set as well. For general use a .3 to .4 needle is ideal and is what I am looking for, having my Infinity for finer work. I then had a look at reviews and it is quite clear that this is actually a precision airbrush and not the cruder spray gun that I thought. I liked the large 15ml cup as well, painting large scale aircraft I often have to refill the much smaller 5ml cups that are standard. Being a H&S the larger cup is interchangeable with smaller H&S cups. My only concern is how the trigger is on top rather than below the needle and whether my finger will cramp up. Looking at the unit I decided it would probably be OK and you hold the brush very differently. So, I decided to take the risk and spend around £180 on one, the most expensive airbrush I have bought. With accessories I actually spent just over £200. John not having one of these in the shop I ordered from Everything Airbrush and it was delivered less than 20 hours after ordering it.

    Here is the Colani is it’s box
    Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_7198.jpeg
Views:	5
Size:	4.9 KB
ID:	1212543

    My initial impression is that it’s a lot smaller than it looked in the pictures I have seen. This is probably because of the over sized paint cup.

    With the brush there is a tool to adjust the movement of the needle, two rings to hep adjust the grip to better fit larger hands. I also bought a new 5ml cup and lid. I never spray with a lid fitted as I guarantee the paint will splash over the top!

    Here she is out of the box.
    Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_7199.jpeg
Views:	5
Size:	5.2 KB
ID:	1212544
    With the larger cup fitted and the two spacers so, it fits my large hand. By the way, if you are left handed the trigger can be swapped around as well.
    Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_7203.jpeg
Views:	5
Size:	5.0 KB
ID:	1212546
    You can see how that large cup gives the appearance of a much larger brush.

    With the 5ml cup fitted as below, giving it a more compact appearance. I will probably do most of my spraying with this smaller cup only using the larger one when needed.
    Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_7204.jpeg
Views:	5
Size:	5.0 KB
ID:	1212547
    Below you can see how it fits my hand. One good feature is how the rear part of the handle twists to fit your hand.
    Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_7202.jpeg
Views:	5
Size:	5.8 KB
ID:	1212545

    I fitted what H&S called a ‘fine pressure control’ others call it a Mac Valve. I usually set my compressor at 15psi and with the fpc wind down the airflow and spray at around the equivalent to 10-12 psi (or sometimes lower), only using the full 15psi to blast cleaner through the unit.
    Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_7206.jpeg
Views:	5
Size:	5.2 KB
ID:	1212548
    Above you can get a better idea of its small size.

    I mentioned how easy these are to break down for a strip clean. Due to the exposed needle this is even easier than the other H&S airbrushes I have used. No tools are needed for this.

    Here is it broken down
    Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_7207.jpeg
Views:	5
Size:	5.1 KB
ID:	1212549
    The cup, obviously, screws off making it very easy to clean the bowl and, as you can see, there is a very small area the paint will touch.

    When I attached my hose there was a hiss. After checking it is clear that the hose has a leak around the quick connector, which is not separate but fitted as part of the hose. I was aware that it has a leak but it has got worse so I ordered another hose.

    Consequently I will review how the airbrush performs once I receive and fit the new hose. Just for now I tested it by spraying a quarter cup of ipa. I can report that it feels good in the hand and has a very smooth action. I may have to adjust the needle movement to suit me when I get to practise with it and, once I am used to it, I am confident that I will be able to get quite thin and ‘tight’ lines. There are no indications that I will suffer from finger cramps.

    So, I will post more once I get the new hose and get to test it properly.

    So far I believe that this is a very good buy and even better than expected.
  • Andy the Sheep
    SMF Supporters
    • Apr 2019
    • 1864
    • Andrea
    • North Eastern Italy

    #2
    Thank you for your review. It's a definitely peculiar airbrush, but it seems to be very user friendly.

    Comment

    • Andy T
      SMF Supporters
      • Apr 2021
      • 3239
      • Sheffield

      #3
      I always thought the Colani was a bit of an oddball with it's trigger on top/side but I'll be very interested to hear how you get on with it.

      I've read your text twice so apologies if I've missed it, but does it work like the ps275 where air comes out first, then paint on a further pull, or is it more like a single action?

      Comment

      • Waspie
        • Mar 2023
        • 3488
        • Doug
        • Fraggle Rock

        #4
        Thanks for the review Barry. I'm having a look around for a similar style AB since I knackered mine by what I assume was over tightening. (That or cheapo metal as mine was at the bottom end of the market.) But for a freebie, I can't whinge too much. (At least I have a compressor!).

        Comment

        • Jim R
          SMF Supporters
          • Apr 2018
          • 15653
          • Jim
          • Shropshire

          #5
          Very interesting Barry.
          I have looked at the Colani a few times and never really understood it. I couldn't figure out how it fitted in the hand. That is now clear from your photo. It certainly is an innovative design. Being able to alter the needle/nozzle is a real bonus. I can certainly see the benefits of a pistol grip AB. I use my GSI Creos Mr Hobby PS275 more than my H&S or my Iwata - you may remember you advised me on the purchase.
          I look forward to your full review.
          [HEADING=2][/HEADING]

          Comment

          • BarryW
            SMF Supporters
            • Jul 2011
            • 6010

            #6
            Originally posted by Andy T
            I always thought the Colani was a bit of an oddball with it's trigger on top/side but I'll be very interested to hear how you get on with it.

            I've read your text twice so apologies if I've missed it, but does it work like the ps275 where air comes out first, then paint on a further pull, or is it more like a single action?
            Hi Andy.
            Yes it is double action. Initially as you pull the trigger only air is allowed through and then as you pull back further paint starts coming through. The tool is to adjust the amount of pull before air comes through. I will be experimenting with that. You can feel a ‘bite’ at the point at which paint starts.

            Comment

            • Mickc1440
              SMF Supporters
              • Apr 2018
              • 4775

              #7
              Look forward to seeing how you get on with it

              Comment

              • BarryW
                SMF Supporters
                • Jul 2011
                • 6010

                #8
                The new hose has not yet been delivered but, being impatient, I got out the Duck Tape! Not a perfect solution and it still hisses a bit but I was able to do a little spraying of the wheel wells on my 1/32 B24D.

                Well, it did feel a little odd at first but I had good control, it sprayed well and the action was smooth.

                I also played around to get some reasonably fine lines and that looked good.

                I will still need to practise a lot when the new hose arrives and I will post some pics when I do. So far so good and I am confident that within a short period the spraying position will feel more natural.

                Comment

                • Andy T
                  SMF Supporters
                  • Apr 2021
                  • 3239
                  • Sheffield

                  #9
                  Originally posted by BarryW
                  Hi Andy.
                  Yes it is double action.
                  Thanks Barry.

                  I avoided that particular phrase as I've seen some people banging on about how a trigger can't truly be called dual action, so played it safe :smiling3:

                  Personally, what else would you call it?

                  Comment

                  • BarryW
                    SMF Supporters
                    • Jul 2011
                    • 6010

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Andy T
                    Thanks Barry.

                    I avoided that particular phrase as I've seen some people banging on about how a trigger can't truly be called dual action, so played it safe :smiling3:

                    Personally, what else would you call it?
                    Well the pull of the trigger releases both air and paint, in that order, so one action, two effects, that’s dual action in my book.

                    Comment

                    • Jim R
                      SMF Supporters
                      • Apr 2018
                      • 15653
                      • Jim
                      • Shropshire

                      #11
                      Originally posted by BarryW
                      Yes it is double action. Initially as you pull the trigger only air is allowed through and then as you pull back further paint starts coming through
                      That is one of the biggest advantages of these airbrushes. You can't avoid the recommended "air on then paint on - paint off then air off". This sequence avoids paint splatter and reduces tip drying.

                      Comment

                      • Andy T
                        SMF Supporters
                        • Apr 2021
                        • 3239
                        • Sheffield

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Jim R
                        That is one of the biggest advantages of these airbrushes. You can't avoid the recommended "air on then paint on - paint off then air off". This sequence avoids paint splatter and reduces tip drying.
                        I see that H&S have designed this into the new "conventional" Ultra. Aimed squarely at those starting out, it prevents the needle from being pulled back for paint until the air is on.

                        It would certainly have helped me acclimatise after decades of using a trigger!

                        Comment

                        • JR
                          • May 2015
                          • 18273

                          #13
                          Originally posted by Andy T
                          I see that H&S have designed this into the new "conventional" Ultra. Aimed squarely at those starting out, it prevents the needle from being pulled back for paint until the air is on.

                          It would certainly have helped me acclimatise after decades of using a trigger!
                          Think I'm with you on that Andy.

                          Comment

                          • Waspie
                            • Mar 2023
                            • 3488
                            • Doug
                            • Fraggle Rock

                            #14
                            Originally posted by Andy T
                            I see that H&S have designed this into the new "conventional" Ultra. Aimed squarely at those starting out, it prevents the needle from being pulled back for paint until the air is on.

                            It would certainly have helped me acclimatise after decades of using a trigger!
                            Seriously looking at the Ultra as my next AB. Certainly the PR looks good on the Ultra. Seems to address many of the issues I have suffered as a beginner!!

                            Comment

                            • stillp
                              SMF Supporters
                              • Nov 2016
                              • 8087
                              • Pete
                              • Rugby

                              #15
                              Originally posted by Richard48
                              cleaning and stripping down it is a real fag.
                              I think I spend less time stripping and cleaning my airbrush than I do washing out hairy sticks.

                              Originally posted by Richard48

                              If a spray say Tamiya acrylics in the room in booth would there be much overspray or smell?
                              Depends how careful you are, and how good your booth is, but there shouldn't be any discernible smell in your flat. Does your wife use hairspray? Does she use a spraybooth?

                              Pete

                              Comment

                              Working...